mazzie: (Default)
([personal profile] mazzie Oct. 3rd, 2005 09:03 am)
Garrison Keillor has gone around the bend.
I mean, really.
The poem he read on Writer's Almanac this morning is a clear sign to me of not only that, but that the entire poetry community has lost its collective mind. Or never had one.
I mean, really.
When I heard him announce the title of the poem he was going to read, in the 6:30 haze of pre-dawn twilight and just-awake haze, I thought "surely I didn't hear him right."
Oh, I did. "The Retarded Children Play Baseball" by Wesley McNair
I mean, really:

The Retarded Children Play Baseball

Never mind the coaches who try
to teach them the game,

and think of the pleasure

of the large-faced boy
on second who raises hand and glove
straight up making the precise

shape of a ball, even though
the ball's now over
the outfield. And think of the left

and right fielders going deeper
just to watch its roundness
materialize out of the sky

and drop at their feet. Both teams
are so in love with this moment
when the bat makes the ball jump

or fly that when it happens
everybody shouts, and the girl
with slanted eyes on first base

leaps off to let the batter by.
Forget the coaches shouting back
about the way the game is played

and consider the game
they're already playing, or playing
perhaps elsewhere on some other field,

like the shortstop, who stands transfixed
all through the action, staring
at what appears to be nothing.

When he said the name of the poem again at the end, I shouted from bed in the dark "ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!" (Which rather startled my companion, who, after I brought it up again a half hour later, suggested I let it go.)

I mean, really.

From: [identity profile] phillyexpat.livejournal.com


Yet another sign that the world is ending . . .

Granted, I just think it's a bad poem outside the subject matter-the imagery seems murky to me.

From: [identity profile] mazzie.livejournal.com


i mean i hate to be so critical, but how the FUCK did this get published? and i am not published because ...? and if i submitted this to the new yorker they would ...? yeah, i'd hear the peals of laughter from here. i've considered checking the author out but i am afraid it would depress me more.

From: [identity profile] phillyexpat.livejournal.com


I could go on and on about the dreck that gets called "art." But, in the meantime, let's just call it like it is-the Emperor's New Clothes mentality. I think it's kind of like a piece of obscure structure or a David Lynch movie (and I admit, I enjoy Lynch, even if I'm not quite sure what in the hell he's trying to say)-no one wants to admit that they don't understand it once a member of the hoi polloi calls it genius.

Trust me, it's not going to be one of those poems that stands the test of time.

From: [identity profile] motherwell.livejournal.com

Yeah, he's losing it...


Last I heard, Keillor was suing someone to stop distribution of a T-shirt that said "Prairie Ho Companion."

From: [identity profile] mazzie.livejournal.com

Re: Yeah, he's losing it...


I heard about that, too.
He's really ... yeah. Wow.
What an exciting way to wake up.

From: [identity profile] motherwell.livejournal.com

Re: Yeah, he's losing it...


I guess he's going for the same heartstrings that got pulled with "Scorn Not His Simplicity" (which is now becoming Bush's anthem).

From: [identity profile] queenmabwords.livejournal.com


I am starting to think that he's just going for a response, negative or whatever.

From: [identity profile] mazzie.livejournal.com


well, it worked! I was telling Jan I am going to write him a letter that goes something like this:
Dear Garrison,
Are you fucking kidding me?!

From: [identity profile] motherwell.livejournal.com


Well, that gets right to the point. Of course, it would make him blush, but maybe he needs the shock...

From: [identity profile] peaceful-fox.livejournal.com


I've just written another one:
"The Eccentric Radio Host Reads Bad Poetry"

From: [identity profile] mazzie.livejournal.com


oh jesus he's still alive.
the quotable moose? *cry*
kenshardik: Raven (Default)

From: [personal profile] kenshardik


If the Frugal Gormet and James Lipton had a wild night of debauchery involving cooking sherry and the works of James Dean....

From: [identity profile] blueinva.livejournal.com


The only thing that made me smile here is that I can hear the *exact* way you'd have said "ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!" and then they less loud, but even more furious way you'd say it later...
.